In my earlier article, Proposed Adjustments to the Federal EV Tax Credit score Handed by the Home of Representatives, I outlined and analyzed 13 proposed modifications to IRC 30D (federal EV tax credit score). Due to the a number of and nuanced variables included within the Home invoice laws, it’s essential have deep data on all the pieces from the worth of the EV, the place it’s assembled, whether or not it’s assembled in a union manufacturing unit, battery measurement, and the place the battery cells are made to find out what the long run tax credit score quantity may really be.
The truth is, there are doubtlessly 9 totally different tax credit score quantities from $0 to $12,500 beneath the proposed tax credit score modifications within the invoice handed by the US Home of Representatives on November 20. On this temporary article I’ll share the three eventualities that result in an EV being fully disqualified from any out there tax credit score quantity.
1. Battery is beneath 10kWh: At the moment solely 5 PHEVs wouldn’t meet the proposed 10 kWh threshold:
- Toyota Prius Prime (8.8 kWh)
- Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid (8.8 kWh)
- Hyundai IONIQ PHEV (8.9 kWh)
- Kia Niro PHEV (8.9 kWh)
- Ferrari SF90 Stradale (8.8 kWh – however which exceeds the MRSP cap and wouldn’t qualify anyway).
Of those 5, the Toyota Prius Prime is the one one which sells in any vital quantity. With Chevrolet Bolt manufacturing halted, the Prius Prime is more likely to end 2021 in third (after the Tesla Fashions Y and three) or 4th after the Toyota RAV4 Prime. However all of those PHEVs have batteries of round 9 kWh and they also might simply be upgraded to 10 kWh to qualify for the tax credit score.
2. Exceeds the Producers Instructed Retail Worth (MSRP) Cap: The Home proposed modifications institute worth caps based mostly on MSRP of $80,000 and $55,000. What isn’t solely clear are the small print behind apply the MSRP cap. Is it utilized to the bottom trim of an EV mannequin, and so that every one different mannequin trims and variants that exceed the MSRP cap nonetheless qualifies? Or does the cap apply to every mannequin trim?
So for instance, the bottom MSRP on the Ford F-150 Lightning Professional is $39,974. However there can even be a Ford F-150 Lightning Platinum journey with a beginning MSRP of $90,474. What the invoice doesn’t make clear is that if the Platinum model nonetheless qualifies as a result of there’s the Professional base trim that falls beneath the $80,000 MSRP cap. Most trade observers I’ve spoken with consider that the invoice provision is dictated by the EV mannequin’s base trim — which means another trim would nonetheless qualify even when it exceeded the relevant MSRP cap. After all we presume that the bottom trim mannequin should really be out there to buy, and never simply deliberate for the long run.
The MSRP worth caps by automobile physique kind are:
- Vans: $80,000.
- Sport Utility Automobiles (SUVs): $80,000.
- Pickup Vehicles: $80,000.
- Different (Some other automobile kind): $55,000.
A second variable is the decrease $55,000 MSRP cap for automobiles categorised as “Different.” Whereas the “Different” classification isn’t really outlined within the invoice, it clearly consists of sedans, hatchback, sports activities automobiles, station wagons, roadsters, and coupes. However isn’t clear is that if some crossovers will fall beneath the “Different” class and never the SUV classification? The Ford Mustang Mach-E, for instance, is classed by the EPA as a station wagon – so it falls beneath “Different” and the $55,000 cap — however the Mach-E just isn’t affected because of its base MSRP of $42,895. Nonetheless, the Mustang Mach-E GT has a beginning MSRP of $59,995. So relying upon the definition of how the MSRP is utilized, the Mach-E GT both will or is not going to be eligible for the federal EV tax credit score.
And if the Cadillac LYRIQ, which at present has a base MSRP of $58,795, is classed as a station wagon (very doable), it might fall beneath the “Different” class and exceed the $55,000 MSRP cap and thus can be disqualified fully from eligibility. If categorized as an SUV, nevertheless, the LYRIQ would qualify for the utmost $12,500 tax credit score.
As such, till we all know the specifics of how the MSRP rule is utilized together with definitions of the automobile kind classifications, it’s troublesome to be exact on what number of EVs can be disqualified because of exceeding the MSRP cap. That mentioned, the EVs under are fairly sure to be disqualified except these which can be on the bubble just like the BMW i4 eDrive40 ($55,400), BMW 530e ($55,500), and BMW iX xDrive50 ($83,200) have their MSRP decreased to come back beneath the cap. And a few of these EVs just like the GMC Hummer EV will see lower-priced trims (Hummer EV2 at $79,995) within the coming years that might be beneath the MSRP cap.
- Audi e-tron GT Premium Plus quottro
- Bentley Bentagya Hybrid
- BMW i4 eDrive40 (MSRP is $55,400 and can possible be decreased)
- BMW iX xDrive50 (MSRP is $83,200 and can possible be decreased)
- BMW 745e xDrive
- BMW 530e (MSRP is $55,500 and would possible be decreased beneath the cap by BMW)
- GMC Hummer EV (EV2 anticipated in 2024 can be beneath the cap)
- Genesis eG80
- Karma Revero GT
- Kia EV6 First Version (Assuming it’s categorised as “Different”; later based mostly trims would qualify)
- Lucid Air
- Mercedes-Benz EQE
- Mercedes-Benz EQS
- Porsche Panamera E-Hybrid
- Porsche Taycan 4 Cross Tourismo
- Porsche Taycan
- Vary Rover Sport PHEV
- Vary Rover PHEV
- Tesla Mannequin S
- Tesla Mannequin X
- Volvo S90 T8 PHEV
- Volvo V60 Recharge
One attention-grabbing have an effect on of the MSRP cap is that some OEMs could transfer up launch dates of their lower-priced trims if that brings the mannequin beneath the relevant MSRP cap. The GMC Hummer is one instance with its lowest worth trim, the Hummer EV2 at $79,995 at present slated for 2024. Relying upon how the MSRP caps are utilized, availability of the Hummer EV2 at beneath the $80,000 SUV cap might make the dearer trims additionally eligible. However this can be a key facet of the textual content of the invoice that also lacks readability.
3. Closing Meeting is Not within the US (Jan 1, 2027): “Closing meeting” on this case doesn’t embody the “Home Content material” requirement of being assembled in a manufacturing unit with a collective bargaining settlement (union). EVs assembled in another country — whether or not Canada, Mexico, Japan, Germany, South Korea or elsewhere — wouldn’t be eligible for any degree of tax credit score. Nonetheless, EVs assembled within the US however not in a union manufacturing unit, would nonetheless be eligible for the tax credit score, however not the $4,500 bonus quantity coated within the earlier article.
Since many foreign-headquartered automakers have introduced plans to provide EVs within the US within the coming years, this provision is most probably to have an effect on the next forms of EVs:
- Low-volume, luxurious/premium automobiles: In principle these would come with some fashions from Porsche, Bentley, Vary Rover, Jaguar, Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and others — however most of the EV fashions from these manufacturers would possible exceed the MSRP caps anyway. So the US requirement could have minimal affect on the luxurious OEMs, except they don’t transfer manufacturing of their higher-volume promoting EVs to the US. An instance might be an EV such because the BMW i4.
- EVs from Asian begin ups: This may occasionally embody OEMs similar to BYD, Xpeng, Nio, and others seeking to enter the US market however ready to determine a producing base within the US as soon as they’ve reached a important mass in gross sales the US.
- US importers: These would apply to fashions from firms similar to Kandi America which import EVs from China after which put by a homologation course of to make the automobiles authorized within the US.
It stays to be seen what modifications the US Senate will make to the proposed tax credit score modifications, or if the BBBA will even obtain the mandatory 50 votes as soon as the textual content of the invoice is finalized. Nonetheless, if it does move principally as is, we are going to in all probability see many MSRP and mannequin commonplace characteristic modifications in addition to extra foreign-based OEMs assembling EVs within the US later this decade. I’d additionally count on Toyota and Subaru to extend the dimensions of the battery packs simply over 1 kWh to succeed in the proposed 10 kWh battery minimal.
Associated Articles on the Federal EV Tax Credit score